Lesson 3.5 — Exercise: Mini-SOTA Analysis
About this exercise
This lesson replicates the collaborative mini-SOTA exercise from Training 3. You will work through a structured research planning template for one of four Big Science procurement scenarios, applying the SOTA methodology taught in Lessons 3.2 and 3.3. Download the exercise handout, choose your scenario, and complete all seven tasks before reviewing.
The four scenarios
| Scenario | Context | Requirement | Challenge |
|---|---|---|---|
| A — Advanced Radiation Detection for Particle Accelerator Safety | BSO needs real-time radiation monitoring covering a 2 km facility | Sub-second detection, integration with emergency shutdown, pattern recognition | Existing systems cover smaller areas and lack predictive capability |
| B — Predictive Maintenance for Research Infrastructure | BSO operates complex machinery (€100M value), downtime costs €200k/day | Predict failures 48–72h in advance, integrate with 15 legacy systems | No training data available for this specific equipment type |
| C — Sustainable Energy Storage for Large-Scale Research Facilities | BSO needs 20 MWh storage, 95% efficiency, 20-year lifespan | Peak shaving, grid stability, renewable integration | Commercial batteries don’t meet scale/efficiency requirements |
| D — Quantum-Safe Cybersecurity for Sensitive Research Data | BSO handles data that must remain secure for 30+ years (quantum computer threat) | Encrypt 10 PB data, post-quantum algorithms, international data sharing | Standards still emerging, few commercial solutions |
Your task — for your assigned scenario, complete all seven sections in the handout:
- Research plan — what information do you need? List the key questions your SOTA must answer.
- Data sources and search strategies — which databases, networks, and desk research methods will you use? (Think: patent databases, CORDIS, TED, trade shows, expert interviews, peer BSO procurement results.)
- TRL assessment — what is the likely TRL range of existing solutions? Explain your reasoning.
- Supplier types — list 3–5 potential supplier types or categories that could address this need.
- Market maturity assessment — is the market ready for PPI, PCP, or Innovation Partnership? Justify your choice using TRL and market dynamics.
- Key risks and unknowns — identify 3 risks or open questions that require further investigation (e.g. through an OMC).
- Any other inputs — what else would you want to know before finalising your procurement strategy?
After completing your analysis, compare your findings with peers or discuss with your procurement team. In the live training, each group presented a 5-minute summary — use this as a self-check: could you present your findings clearly in 5 minutes?
Debrief notes (after you have completed your own analysis)
There is no single correct answer. Good SOTA analysis is characterised by:
- Mapping multiple solution types, not just one technology
- Assigning a TRL range to each (not a single level — your first guess is often wrong)
- Identifying the specific gap between current SOTA and the required performance
- Instrument recommendation that flows directly from the gap finding
- Acknowledging unknowns honestly — what would the OMC need to validate?

